
Legally reviewed by Massachusetts bankruptcy attorney Michael Goldstein. Last reviewed: September 10, 2026.
Can tax debt be discharged in bankruptcy?
Some old income tax debt can be discharged in Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy, but only when the return was filed on time and the debt clears strict timing rules. If you file bankruptcy in Massachusetts, you are in the First Circuit, where a return filed even one day after its deadline does not count as a “return” at all. The tax on that return can never be discharged. Separately, late-filing and late-payment penalties follow their own three-year clock and are often dischargeable even when the underlying tax is not.
If you are considering a liquidation case more broadly, see our Chapter 7 bankruptcy in Massachusetts page for how Chapter 7 works, who may qualify, and what the filing process involves.
What Are the Three-Year, Two-Year, and 240-Day Rules?
Federal tax debt can only be wiped out in bankruptcy if it clears all three of these tests. Miss one, and the debt survives. All three come from 11 U.S.C. § 507(a)(8), which the discharge rule in 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(1) incorporates by reference.
Due date
The return’s due date, including any extension, must be more than three years before you file.
Filing date
You must have actually filed the return at least two years before you file for bankruptcy.
Assessment
The tax must have been assessed more than 240 days before you file. A tax that hasn’t been assessed yet but still can be, such as a balance from an audit that’s still open, fails this test.
Does Filing a Massachusetts Tax Return Late Permanently Block Discharge?
This is the part most national websites get wrong for Massachusetts filers.
The two-year rule assumes you actually filed a “return.” The Bankruptcy Code defines that term to mean a document that satisfies the deadline under the tax law that applies to it, not just any document with your income on it. In Fahey v. Massachusetts Department of Revenue, 779 F.3d 1 (1st Cir. 2015), the First Circuit held that a Massachusetts income tax return filed after its due date isn’t a “return” for bankruptcy purposes at all, no matter how many years later you eventually file for bankruptcy. Four Massachusetts filers in that case had filed their state returns late, then waited more than two years before filing bankruptcy, thinking that satisfied the rule. The First Circuit disagreed: the late-filed return never started the two-year clock, so the tax on it can’t be discharged. The First Circuit had a chance to reconsider Fahey in In re Kriss, No. 21-1206 (1st Cir. Nov. 22, 2022), and didn’t take it. The court decided that case on other grounds, so Fahey still binds every bankruptcy court in Massachusetts.
First Circuit — Fahey
A return filed even one day after its due date is not a “return.” The tax on it is permanently excepted from discharge, no matter how long ago it was eventually filed.
Eleventh Circuit — Shek
947 F.3d 770 (2020). Looks at the full circumstances around a late return rather than an automatic bar, which can let some late filers still qualify. The Supreme Court declined to resolve this split in 2024.
If you filed in Massachusetts, the stricter First Circuit rule applies to you regardless of what you may have read about a more forgiving standard elsewhere.
A filer’s 2018 Massachusetts return was due April 15, 2019, but wasn’t filed until eight months later. Filing Chapter 7 in 2026, that return is old enough on paper to clear the three-year and two-year windows. Under Fahey, it doesn’t matter. The late filing permanently excepts the tax on that return from discharge.
This example is illustrative only and does not describe an actual client’s case or outcome.
Are IRS or DOR Penalties Dischargeable Even If the Tax Itself Is Not?
Often, yes, and this surprises a lot of people. Penalties for filing late or paying late don’t follow the 3-2-240 test above. They’re governed by a separate provision, 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(7), which discharges a governmental penalty once the “transaction or event” behind it, generally the return’s original due date, is more than three years old. That clock runs independently of whether the underlying tax survives.
Tax & interest
Governed by the 3-2-240 test above. If the return was late under Fahey, the tax and its interest survive bankruptcy regardless of how old the debt is.
Late-filing & late-payment penalties
Governed by § 523(a)(7)(B). Dischargeable once the return’s due date is more than three years old, even if the tax attached to it is not.
The practical result: you can walk out of a Chapter 7 case still owing the tax and interest on an old return in full, while the penalty attached to that same balance is wiped out, because the tax rule and the penalty rule don’t defer to each other. Two things never discharge regardless of timing: payroll trust fund taxes an employer withheld from employees but never turned over, and any tax tied to a fraudulent return or a willful attempt to evade it.
Do I Still Need to Notify Massachusetts DOR If I File Bankruptcy?
Yes. Filing your federal bankruptcy petition doesn’t automatically notify the Massachusetts Department of Revenue. If you have a potential DOR liability, you’re required to contact DOR’s Bankruptcy Unit separately. This applies whether you’re filing Chapter 7, 13, or another chapter.
Mail: Massachusetts Department of Revenue, Bankruptcy Unit, PO Box 7090, Boston, MA 02204-7090
Does a Chapter 7 Discharge Remove a Massachusetts DOR Tax Lien?
No, and this is another point generic content tends to skip. A discharge wipes out your personal obligation to pay a dischargeable tax debt. It doesn’t touch a DOR lien already recorded against your property, because the lien is a separate claim against the property, not against you personally.
- The assessed liability, interest, and penalties are paid in full
- A judgment against you on the liability is satisfied
- DOR accepts a bond guaranteeing payment
- The liability becomes legally unenforceable because the collection statute of limitations, currently ten years from assessment and extendable, has run
A bankruptcy discharge by itself isn’t on that list. If DOR recorded a lien before you filed, expect it to still be there after your case closes.
What About Chapter 13?
Tax debt that can’t be discharged doesn’t just sit there in Chapter 13. It gets paid in full as a priority claim over the life of your plan, typically three to five years, while the automatic stay stops collection in the meantime. That can make Chapter 13 the better fit when most of your tax debt fails the timing tests above. See our Chapter 13 bankruptcy page for how a plan works.
The bottom line
Old income tax debt can sometimes be discharged, but “old” isn’t just about the calendar. Whether your return was filed on time matters as much as how long ago it was due, especially in Massachusetts. And even when the tax survives, the penalties attached to it might not. If you’re not sure where your specific tax years fall on these tests, that’s exactly the kind of question worth a direct conversation before you file.
Not sure where your tax debt stands?
Attorney Michael Goldstein can review your specific tax years and filing history and explain what the 3-2-240 rules mean for your case.
Call (781) 745-3792Continue reading
- Tax DebtIRS and Massachusetts Tax Debt Resolution Outside Bankruptcy
- Tax DebtSettling IRS Debt: Your Options Before Bankruptcy
- Chapter 13Using Chapter 13 to Stop a Foreclosure
- Property & ExemptionsWill I Lose Everything If I File Bankruptcy?
Michael Goldstein is a Massachusetts bankruptcy attorney who has represented individual Chapter 7 filers, including cases applying the three-year, two-year, and 240-day rules to discharge old personal income tax debt. More about Attorney Goldstein or schedule a consultation.
- Can bankruptcy stop a lawsuit, judgment or bank levy in Massachusetts? - October 5, 2026
- What happens if I miss a Chapter 13 payment in Massachusetts? - September 27, 2026
- How long after the Meeting of Creditors will I get my Chapter 7 discharge in Massachusetts? - September 21, 2026





